True Crimes and a Lie, Vol. 4

Here's a little sneak peek of the action coming up in the next Campfire Classics!  That's right, it's another True Crimes and a Lie! a gameshow within a podcast, where Heather tries to determine fact from fiction and Ken tries to come up with a snappy tagline.

Can you tell which story is fiction?  And can you guess the super subtle theme that holds these stories together?